Justice & Power
Fatima Benali
She has lost more cases than she has won, and considers several of the losses more useful. Each one moved the line a little.
Fatima Benali keeps a list of the cases she lost, and next to each one, what changed anyway.
It is a longer and more interesting document than her list of wins.
Losing productively
Strategic litigation, she explains, is often about forcing a court to say out loud a thing it would rather leave vague. A loss with clear reasoning can be more useful than a quiet win, because the reasoning is what the next lawyer inherits.
She teaches this to junior colleagues, most of whom find it demoralising for about two years and then indispensable.
She has never given a client the impression that a loss is a good outcome. That distinction, she says, is the whole ethic of the work.
I am not building a career out of these cases. I am building a staircase, and I do not expect to be on it when it is finished.
Go deeper
Sign in with Google to join the conversation. We show your name; we never show your email.
Sign in with GoogleBy signing in you agree to the terms and privacy policy.