AWEsome Women's Club

June 14, 2026

The Lawyer Who Keeps a List of Her Losses

Fatima Benali has lost more than she has won. She will explain, patiently, why you are asking the wrong question about that.

The Lawyer Who Keeps a List of Her Losses
Photo by Placeholder

You keep a written list of cases you have lost. Why?

Because I would otherwise remember them wrongly. Memory is generous to us. It smooths things. If I write down what happened and what changed anyway, I have a record I cannot flatter.

What does the list actually look like?

Two columns. On the left, the case and the year. On the right, one sentence: what moved. Sometimes the sentence is a statute that got amended four years later. Sometimes it is a paragraph of reasoning that another lawyer used to win in a different city. Sometimes the right-hand column says nothing. Those are the ones I read most often.

Is that not a bleak document?

It is the least bleak document I own. The bleak version would be a list of wins, because I would have to believe those were mine. They were not. They were the accumulation of everyone who lost before me.

You tell junior colleagues this and you say it takes them two years to accept it.

About two years, yes. They arrive believing that a good lawyer wins. It is not an unreasonable belief. It is simply not how this particular kind of law functions.

The work is to force a court to say a thing out loud. A vague win leaves the next person with nothing. A clear loss leaves them a map.

How do you explain that to a client who has just lost?

I do not. Ever.

That distinction is the entire ethic of the job. What is useful to the movement and what has happened to this woman are two separate facts, and I will not let the first one be spoken in the same room as the second.

She lost. She is entitled to have that be the whole of it, with me, on that day.

Do you ever want to win more?

Constantly. I am not serene about this. People mistake the list for serenity.

I want to win every single one of them, and I go home angry, and then some months later a colleague in Rabat cites a paragraph from something I lost in 2011 and wins with it, and I add a line to the right-hand column.

That is not consolation. It is just the shape of the thing.

What would you tell a woman starting out now?

That she should find out early whether she can tolerate being useful without being credited, because that is most of it.

And that she should keep her own list. Not for morale. For accuracy.

Conversation

No comments yet